Old Town vs BKC Kayaks: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The old town vs BKC kayak comparison highlights two distinct approaches to fishing gear. Both brands design vessels for angling, offering rod holders and stable platforms. The main difference lies in propulsion and seating. The Old Town model comes with a motor and single-seat configuration, while the BKC option is a paddle-driven tandem kayak. You need to decide whether electric power or shared space fits your routine.
Key differences
| Aspect | Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak | BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 10 ft 6 in | 12 ft 2 in |
| Capacity | 525 lb | 600 lb |
| Propulsion | 45 lb thrust trolling motor | Paddle with motor mount |
| Seating | Single dual-layer mesh seat | Two padded seats |
| Person Capacity | 1 person | 2 to 3 persons |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak if
- You want a single-person boat with built-in electric propulsion.
- You prefer a shorter, more maneuverable hull for tight spots.
- You value a dedicated rudder system for precise steering.
Choose BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak if
- You need to carry a passenger or extra gear safely.
- You prefer manual paddle control over battery-powered motors.
- You want a wider beam for enhanced stability while standing.
Verdict: Choose the Old Town if you prioritize motorized convenience and solo control. Pick the BKC if you require tandem seating and higher weight limits for shared trips. Your choice depends on whether you fish alone or with others.
Old Town vs BKC Kayak Specs
Propulsion system
The Old Town Sportsman 106 comes equipped with a Minn Kota 12-volt trolling motor delivering 45 pounds of thrust. This motorized setup allows for hands-free navigation, though the battery is sold separately. In contrast, the BKC Brooklyn 12.5 does not include a motor. It features a dedicated mount area where you can install a trolling motor of your choice. The BKC relies on paddle power as its primary propulsion method. If you prefer immediate motorized capability without extra purchases, the Old Town holds the advantage.
Person capacity
The Old Town Sportsman 106 is designed as a single-person kayak. It features a cushioned floor pad and a premium dual-layer Textilene mesh seat for one angler. The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is a tandem sit-on-top kayak rated for two to three people. It includes two padded seats and multiple footrest positions to accommodate different heights. This makes the BKC suitable for fishing with a partner or family member, while the Old Town is strictly for solo use. The BKC wins for group fishing.
Maximum capacity
Weight limits differ significantly between these two vessels. The Old Town Sportsman 106 has a maximum capacity of 525 pounds. Its usable capacity for people and gear is listed at 329 pounds. The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 offers a higher maximum capacity of 600 pounds. This extra capacity allows you to carry more gear, tackle, or additional passengers without compromising stability. The BKC provides a higher weight limit for heavy loads.
Construction material
The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is built using rotomolded single-piece HDPE construction. This material is noted for being impact and UV resistant, which helps the kayak withstand rough handling and sun exposure. The Old Town Sportsman 106 data does not specify the exact construction material, though it features a durable design with through-hull wiring kits and a universal transducer mount. Without explicit material details for the Old Town, the BKC has the edge for verified impact resistance.
Length and beam
The Old Town Sportsman 106 is 10 feet 6 inches long. The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is longer at 12 feet 2 inches. The BKC also has a wider beam of 34 inches, which provides outstanding balance for standing casts or rough waters. The Old Town uses a large rudder for boat control, which aids maneuverability. The longer length of the BKC may offer better tracking in open water, while the Old Town is more compact.
Fishing features
Both kayaks offer robust fishing setups. The Old Town includes customizable accessory tracks, a custom tackle box, plenty of rod holders, and three through-hull wiring kits for electronics. It also has a universal transducer mount. The BKC comes with six rod holders, consisting of four flush-mounted and two articulating types. It also features an accessory-friendly layout for custom rigging. The Old Town offers more integrated electronics preparation, while the BKC provides more immediate rod holder options.
Which Old Town Or BKC Kayak Fits You
Anglers wanting motorized hands-free navigation
The Old Town Sportsman 106 includes a 45-pound thrust Minn Kota trolling motor. This 12-volt system allows for hands-free steering, which is useful for long days on the water. You get a dedicated motor console and transducer mount. Note that the battery is not included, so you must purchase it separately to operate the propulsion system.
Groups needing space for two or three people
The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is a tandem sit-on-top kayak designed for two adults plus a child or extra gear. It features a 600-pound capacity and a 34-inch beam for stability. This model includes two padded seats and two paddles. It is ideal if you need to share the experience or carry significant fishing equipment.
Solo paddlers prioritizing lightweight portability
The Old Town model weighs 121 pounds, which is manageable for solo transport despite its motor. It has a 525-pound capacity with 329 pounds usable for gear. The 10-foot 6-inch length offers maneuverability. If you prefer a single-seat configuration with a rudder for control, this compact motorized kayak suits your solo fishing trips well.
The products compared
Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak
Best for: Solo anglers needing electric thrust and rudder control
- Length
- 10 ft 6 in
- Capacity
- 525-pound maximum capacity
- Person Capacity
- Solo
- Propulsion
- Minn Kota trolling motor
- Seat Type
- Dual-layer Textilene mesh seat
- Fishing Features
- Rod holders, universal transducer mount
View on Amazon: Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak Affiliate link
The Old Town Sportsman 106 is a 10-foot 6-inch fishing kayak with a 525-pound capacity. It features a 45-pound thrust Minn Kota trolling motor and a 121-pound weight. The dual-layer Textilene mesh seat and extra-large rudder provide comfort and control. It includes customizable accessory tracks, rod holders, and wiring kits for electronics. This motorized option suits anglers seeking electric propulsion and stable handling.
Pros
- 12-volt Minn Kota trolling motor with 45 pounds of thrust
- 525-pound maximum capacity with 329 pounds usable capacity
- Extra-large rudder for excellent forward and reverse control
- Dual-layer Textilene mesh seat for all-day comfort
- Three through-hull wiring kits for fish finder installation
Cons
- Motor battery is not included with the kayak
- Paddle is sold separately
- 121-pound weight requires careful transport planning
Good fit if
- You want electric propulsion without manual pedaling
- You need a stable platform for gear and electronics
- You prefer rudder steering for precise maneuverability
Skip if
- You are looking for a lightweight manual kayak
- You do not want to purchase a separate battery
- You need a tandem kayak for two people
Verdict: Old Town Sportsman 106 Motorized Kayak fits anglers who need electric thrust and rudder steering for precise control. It is a solid choice for solo fishing trips where stability and electronics integration matter more than manual paddling.
BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak
Best for: tandem fishing and gear capacity
- Seating Style
- Sit-on-top
- Construction
- Rotomolded HDPE
- Length
- 12.5 ft
- Capacity
- 600 lb
- Person Capacity
- 2 to 3 person
- Propulsion
- Paddle, trolling motor mount
View on Amazon: BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak Affiliate link
The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is a 12-foot 2-inch sit-on-top kayak built for two to three people. It features a 34-inch beam for stability and a 600-pound capacity. You get six rod holders, including two articulating ones, and two padded seats. The rotomolded HDPE hull is durable and includes a trolling motor mount. It comes with two paddles and fits various footrest positions.
Pros
- 600-pound weight capacity
- Six rod holders for fishing
- Trolling motor-ready mount
- Includes two paddles and seats
Cons
- Heavier at 70 pounds
- No built-in electric motor
- Requires manual paddling
Good fit if
- You need a stable tandem kayak
- You want to add a trolling motor
- You fish with a partner or child
Skip if
- You prefer a solo kayak
- You want a lightweight single-person boat
- You need a motorized kayak out of the box
Verdict: BKC Brooklyn 12.5 Tandem Kayak offers high capacity and fishing features for groups. It suits anglers who share a boat and plan to add their own motor.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Old Town Sportsman 106 Minn Kota Motorized Kayak | BKC 12.5 Tandem Sit-on-Top Fishing Kayak |
|---|---|---|
| Seating Style | not stated | Sit-on-top |
| Construction | not stated | Rotomolded HDPE |
| Length | 10 ft 6 in | 12.5 ft |
| Capacity | 525-pound maximum capacity | 600 lb |
| Person Capacity | Solo | 2 to 3 person |
| Propulsion | Minn Kota trolling motor | Paddle, trolling motor mount |
| Seat Type | Dual-layer Textilene mesh seat | Padded seats |
| Fishing Features | Rod holders, universal transducer mount | 6 rod holders |
| Use | Fishing | Fishing, Lake, River |
| Color | Ember Camo | Camo |
| Size | Length 10 Ft | 12-foot 2-inch |
| Water Type | not stated | Rivers |
| Included Accessories | not stated | Paddle |
| Weight | 121 pounds | 70 pounds |
| Dimensions | not stated | 148 × 32 × 12 inches |
| Model | 01.4064.0103 | UH-TK219 CAMO |
Frequently asked questions
Is Old Town or BKC better for solo fishing?
Old Town is better for solo anglers. The Sportsman 106 is designed for one person. It includes a motor for precise control without paddling. BKC offers a tandem kayak. This model seats up to three people. It is built for groups sharing gear. Choose Old Town for single-person stability and electric propulsion.
Which kayak has more weight capacity?
The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 has higher capacity. It is rated for three persons. Its dimensions are 148 inches long and 32 inches wide. The Old Town Sportsman 106 is a single-person vessel. It weighs 121 pounds. The BKC kayak itself weighs 70 pounds. You get more space and people capacity with the BKC model.
Does the Old Town kayak come with a motor?
Yes, the Old Town Sportsman 106 includes a motor. It uses a Minn Kota 12-volt trolling motor. This system provides 45 pounds of thrust. The battery is sold separately. The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 does not include a motor. You must add your own if needed. The Old Town model is ready for electric navigation.
Which kayak is lighter to transport?
The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is lighter. It weighs 70 pounds. The Old Town Sportsman 106 weighs 121 pounds. The BKC model is easier to carry. The Old Town model is heavier due to its motor and electronics. Consider the weight difference when loading your vehicle. The BKC kayak offers a lighter transport option.
What is the difference in length between the two kayaks?
The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is longer. It measures 148 inches, or 12 feet 2 inches. The Old Town Sportsman 106 is 10 feet long. The BKC model offers more tracking stability due to its length. The Old Town model is more maneuverable. You gain extra paddling distance with the BKC kayak.
Which kayak is better for tandem fishing?
The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is better for tandem use. It seats up to three people. It provides ample room for two anglers and gear. The Old Town Sportsman 106 is a single-person kayak. It is designed for one angler. If you fish with a partner, the BKC model is the practical choice.
Do these kayaks come in camouflage?
Yes, both brands offer camouflage options. The Old Town Sportsman 106 comes in Ember Camo. The BKC Brooklyn 12.5 is available in Camo. Both finishes help blend into natural surroundings. The color choice does not affect performance. Select the pattern that matches your local environment.